Guides · Roofing and care

Shed felt vs EPDM vs shingles

Compare shed roofing felt, EPDM rubber membranes and bitumen shingles by roof pitch, deck, fixing, lifespan claims and price, with named products and maker instructions.

By the Shedworthy teamChecked

Affiliate links: We earn from some links to Wickes through the Awin network. You do not pay more, and it does not change what we recommend. How this works.

Felt, rubber membrane and shingle roof samples
AI-generated editorial illustration

There comes a day in every shed's life when you notice a damp patch on the floor, look up, and find the felt flapping like a pirate flag. Before you reach for the cheapest roll in the shop, it's worth a cup of tea and five minutes' thought about what goes back on. Traditional mineral shed felt is familiar, cheap and easy to patch. EPDM is a single sheet of synthetic rubber, popular on flatter roofs. Bitumen shingles give overlapping "tile" courses on suitably pitched roofs. Each works well on the right roof and badly on the wrong one, and the roof's pitch, deck and edges decide which is which.

Three shed roof covering build-ups
Conceptual diagram, not to scale

The quick comparison

Shed feltEPDM rubber kitBitumen shingles
What it isBitumen-coated felt with a mineral finish, nailed and/or gluedOne-piece synthetic rubber sheet bonded with adhesiveOverlapping bitumen strips nailed to a deck
Roof pitch (from maker info)IKO Shed Felt: 20° or more; 10–20° needs IKO trade underlayPermaRoof describes EPDM as a flat-roofing approach; check the kit maker for pitch limitsBardoline: 12.5° minimum recommended; membrane below 20°
Deck neededSound, flat boards; protruding nails removedClean, dry, dust-free deck; Rubber4Roofs lists new boards as needed for SkyguardFull wooden decking, minimum 12mm (18mm preferred)
Published life claimsUp to 5 years (IKO Shed Felt) to up to 15 years (IKO Super Shed Felt)Skyguard: 50+ years life expectancy; PermaRoof: 50-year service life expectancyWickes: 10-year waterproofing guarantee; Onduline sheet: 5-year warranty
Example price (checked 15 November 2026)About £32 (IKO Black Shed Felt, 10 x 1m) to £51 (IKO Black Super Shed Felt, 8 x 1m) at WickesAbout £56 (Skyguard 4ft–10ft kit) at WickesAbout £40 per 2m² pack (Bardoline) at Wickes
Good forLike-for-like repairs, budget re-roofsPent and low-pitch roofs, fewer joinsApex roofs where looks matter

"Life expectancy" and "guarantee" are the makers' own claims and always depend on correct installation, so read the conditions.

Option 1: traditional shed felt

Felt is the default on most new sheds and the easiest to replace like for like. The IKO Shed Felt installation instructions published by Wickes describe it as a traditional bitumen-coated roofing felt with a fine mineral finish, suited to sheds and other non-inhabited buildings with a roof pitch of 20° or more. The key steps it sets out:

  1. Remove the old felt, hammer down or secure uneven boards (or overlay with ply) and remove or drive home protruding nails.
  2. Unroll the felt on a clean, flat surface at least 30 minutes beforehand (not on the lawn, which may yellow).
  3. Fit the first strip at the lowest part of the roof, overhanging the eaves and edges by 50mm, nailing the top edge at 500mm centres with 13mm galvanised large-head felt nails.
  4. Fold the overhangs down and nail at 50mm intervals.
  5. Overlap each following sheet by 75mm, glue the lap with IKOpro Roofing Felt Adhesive and nail at 50mm intervals.
  6. Finish an apex with a 300mm capping strip glued down 150mm each side, and fix timber strips to the edges for a neat finish.

The instructions also say the felt is easier to handle above 10°C, to avoid wet or very cold weather, and give roll quantities: one roll for an apex or pent shed up to 7 x 5ft, one roll for an 8 x 6ft pent, two rolls for an 8 x 6ft apex. They state an expected life of up to 5 years when installed as instructed.

Wickes lists two grades. The IKO Black Shed Felt - 10 x 1m at Wickes is described as economical, lasting up to 5 years, about £32. The IKO Black Super Shed Felt - 8 x 1m at Wickes is a polyester-based felt that Wickes says lasts up to 15 years, about £51. Both listings say any roof pitched between 10° and 20° needs IKO trade underlay beneath. For laps, the IKOpro High Performance Roofing Felt Adhesive - 2.5L at Wickes (about £23) quotes coverage of 1–1.5m² per litre.

If you want something more robust than nailed felt, the IKO Green Easyseal self-adhesive top sheet (about £61 for 6 x 1m) is a cold-applied, BBA-certified product designed as part of a two-layer system, which Wickes says lasts up to 20 years with the matching underlay.

Wondering whether you can skip the stripping? See can I felt over old shed felt?

Option 2: EPDM rubber membrane

EPDM kits swap many strips and nails for a single bonded sheet. The Skyguard 4ft - 10ft Garden Building Roof Kit at Wickes (about £56) contains 1.0mm EPDM membrane, adhesive, sealant and a roller, and claims a 50+ year life expectancy. Rubber4Roofs, which sells the Skyguard system, describes it as its most cost-effective option, designed specifically for sheds and outbuildings, and lists its drawbacks plainly: only for sheds and outbuildings, black only, new timber boards needed, and the substrate has to be dry before installation.

PermaRoof's shed roof kits use RubberCover EPDM with spray contact adhesive and sealant, carry a lifetime guarantee, and add 300mm to standard-size membranes to allow for overhang. Its installation guide says to fully remove the old covering, work on a clean, dry, dust-free surface, let the membrane relax for 1–2 hours, bond one half at a time, brush out bubbles, trim to leave at least 50mm overhang, then sandwich the edges under timber battens with a sealant bead. Battens are not included.

The catch: EPDM relies on a sound, dry deck and careful edge detailing. A perfect membrane on rotten boards is still a leak waiting to happen.

Option 3: bitumen shingles

Shingles look smarter than felt and suit apex roofs. The Bardoline Classic Slate Rectangular Roof Shingles are about £40 for a 2m² pack of 14 at Wickes. Onduline's technical sheet says each shingle is 100 x 34cm, at seven per m² and 9.4kg/m². Installation is on full wooden decking only (minimum 12mm, preferably 18mm), with a minimum 12.5° pitch recommended, five 20mm large-head galvanised nails per shingle, and a breathable membrane below on pitches under 20°.

One discrepancy to flag: the Wickes listing mentions a 10-year waterproofing guarantee, while the Onduline sheet states a 5-year waterproofing warranty conditional on correct installation. Check which applies before you buy.

Shingles need more time and more nails than felt, and the extra weight and deck thickness mean an old, thin roof may need re-boarding first.

Other kits worth knowing about

Wickes also lists the Onduvilla Roof Kit for 8 x 6ft roofs (about £200, 21 tiles, ridges, verges and screws, 15-year weathering guarantee) and the Coroline Bitumen Shed Roof Kit for 3 x 5m roofs (about £380, 12 corrugated sheets with fixings and trims, 15-year waterproof guarantee). These are lightweight bitumen sheets and tiles, not felt or EPDM, and come with their own fixing rules.

How to choose

  • Match the system to the pitch. Below about 20°, nailed shed felt needs an underlay (per IKO) and shingles need a membrane (per Onduline). PermaRoof describes EPDM as a domestic flat-roofing approach, so check the kit maker's pitch guidance. Check your roof style and which way a pent roof should slope.
  • Fix the deck first. Replace soft or delaminated boards before covering them; every maker above assumes a sound deck.
  • Count the whole system. Nails, adhesive, underlay, trims, battens and ridge strips all add cost.
  • Think about the shed's life. A 50-year membrane on a budget shed may outlast the walls. Check the shed maker's guidance too, for example Forest Garden's help and support pages.
  • Keep it dry inside. A sound roof is the first defence against damp and condensation.

Stay safe up there

Shed roofs are not built to be walked on. HSE's ladder guidance says ladders suit low-risk, short-duration tasks with the right type of ladder and sensible precautions. Work from a stable ladder or platform, never stand on the roof boards, choose a dry, calm day, have a helper, and follow the product instructions to the letter.

The Shedworthy verdict

For a quick, cheap like-for-like fix on a decent pitch, good-quality felt still earns its place. For a low-slope pent roof you never want to think about again, an EPDM kit is the tidy upgrade, provided the deck is sound and dry. For an apex shed that's on show, shingles look the part, at the cost of more time and nails. Pick the one your roof is built for, and your shed will stay dry for many years.

Sources